Alternativa Forum

Raj, slobodna volja, Pakao.

Ovo je diskusija na temu Raj, slobodna volja, Pakao. u podforumu Religija
Citat: Originally Posted by Moldercuker Pa hocu rec da su svi ...

Natrag   Alternativa Forum > Metafizika i duhovnost > Religija

Alternativa Forum


Religija Trajna egzistencijalna karakteristika ljudskog bića

Odgovor
LinkBack Opcije Teme Način Prikaza
Nepročitano 19-04-15, 12:04   #11
padanormalan
 
chameleon's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Jul 2011
Lokacija: prva desno poslije skretanja
Postovi: 12,418
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Citat:
Originally Posted by Moldercuker Pogledaj Post
Pa hocu rec da su svi ti odgovori na pitanja izmisljotina ko i to dvoje, princ i princeza. Mozda je bas nekad/negdje bili dvoje kojima je bilo bas tako kao njima, samo onaj ko je napiso pricu to nezna, slucajno pogodio, a nije ni pogadjo, jednostavno tako izmislio

Tetrapak
Razumio sam ja tebe (i slažem se s tobom) ali izgleda da nisam dovoljno bio precizan.
O čemu god se pričalo, može se govoriti samo o poznatom.
Bog nije poznat jer njegovo postojanje zahtjeva vjeru. Npr. postojanje mačaka ne zahtjeva vjeru da one postoje. Možeš imat vjerovanje da ne postoje ali ćeš si morat objasnit što to mjauče na 4 noge.

Objašnjavanje nepoznatog poznatim može rezultirati samo poznatim.
Zaključak je da se poznatim ne može doći do nepoznatog Boga i tu se treba pitati o čemu poznatom se onda govori.

Analogija bajki koje završavaju sa "i živjeli su sretno" i religije je u tome što i religija koristi poznate životne situacije da uvuče slušatelja u priču i (realno) staje tamo gdje završava poznato.
Kada bi se malo dublje ušlo u psihološku analizu izmišljanja ezoteričkih motiva došlo bi se do projekcija stvarnih svjetovnih pragmatičnih želja i potreba koje putem simbola kreiraju svijet po želji kao emocionalnu kompenzaciju. Iz tog razloga su nastale bajke za djecu i bajke za odrasle.


Stone



Podijeli post!

chameleon je offline   Reply With Quote

Nepročitano 19-04-15, 12:28   #12
padanormalan
 
chameleon's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Jul 2011
Lokacija: prva desno poslije skretanja
Postovi: 12,418
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Citat:
Originally Posted by MadMax111 Pogledaj Post
Odlično sročeno,kratko i jednostavno.
Ovakva pitanja si većina vjernika odbija postaviti zato jer znaju da je cjela priča apsurdna ali lakše je živjeti u neznanju.
Ima svakakvih profila vjernika. Neki znaju ali ne žele znati, drugi ne znaju i ne žele znati, treći znaju ali ne znaju što ne znaju, četvrti znaju pa prigodno kombiniraju poželjno a neprihvatljivo relativiziraju.
To vrijedi za sve teističke ideologije.
Razlika između mainstreama i ostalih je u sposobnosti regrutiranja novih članova i umijeću infiltriranja u društvene sustave moći.


Stone



Podijeli post!

chameleon je offline   Reply With Quote
Nepročitano 19-04-15, 19:01   #13
.
 
DeteSvetla6's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: May 2009
Lokacija: .
Postovi: 8,604
DeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond repute
DeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond repute
Hi!

"Postoje dve mogućnosti.
IIi smo sami u svemiru, ili nismo.
Obe mogućnosti su zastrašujuće."
Artur Klark
DeteSvetla6 je offline   Reply With Quote
DeteSvetla6, hvala ti na korisnom postu!
Jesam (19-04-15)
Nepročitano 19-04-15, 20:11   #14
padanormalan
 
chameleon's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Jul 2011
Lokacija: prva desno poslije skretanja
Postovi: 12,418
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Citat:
Originally Posted by DeteSvetla6 Pogledaj Post
"Postoje dve mogućnosti.
IIi smo sami u svemiru, ili nismo.
Obe mogućnosti su zastrašujuće."
Artur Klark
Ajd razmisli o temi prije nego se uključiš. :D


Stone



Podijeli post!

chameleon je offline   Reply With Quote
chameleon, hvala ti na korisnom postu!
DeteSvetla6 (28-04-15)
Nepročitano 19-04-15, 20:24   #15
Road Warrior
 
MadMax111's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: May 2013
Lokacija: Istra
Postovi: 1,011
MadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond repute
MadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond reputeMadMax111 has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Citat:
Originally Posted by chameleon Pogledaj Post
Ima svakakvih profila vjernika. Neki znaju ali ne žele znati, drugi ne znaju i ne žele znati, treći znaju ali ne znaju što ne znaju, četvrti znaju pa prigodno kombiniraju poželjno a neprihvatljivo relativiziraju.
To vrijedi za sve teističke ideologije.
Razlika između mainstreama i ostalih je u sposobnosti regrutiranja novih članova i umijeću infiltriranja u društvene sustave moći.

Generalizira sam,ionako se sve svede na na istu poantu,lakše ić utabanim putem.
MadMax111 je offline   Reply With Quote
Nepročitano 19-04-15, 21:07   #16
LIK
←↑→↓
 
LIK's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Oct 2009
Lokacija: Tko zna
Postovi: 3,195
LIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond repute
LIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond reputeLIK has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Tema je nepotrebna jer se o svim tim pitanjima raspravljalo i raspravlja se na temi tko je bog ...
LIK je offline   Reply With Quote
Hvala na korisnom postu!
DeteSvetla6 (28-04-15), Diana (19-04-15), Jesam (20-04-15)
Nepročitano 20-04-15, 09:13   #17
Dandapani
 
Jesam's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Mar 2011
Postovi: 14,062
Jesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond repute
Jesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond reputeJesam has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Citat:
Originally Posted by LIK Pogledaj Post
Tema je nepotrebna jer se o svim tim pitanjima raspravljalo i raspravlja se na temi tko je bog ...
Znači da je tam teški off-topik i da se treba preseliti ovamo.


slobodni.net za slobodni svijet



Podijeli post!

Jesam je offline   Reply With Quote
Jesam, hvala ti na korisnom postu!
Diana (21-04-15)
Nepročitano 28-04-15, 20:26   #18
padanormalan
 
chameleon's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Jul 2011
Lokacija: prva desno poslije skretanja
Postovi: 12,418
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
chameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond reputechameleon has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

Citat:
Originally Posted by LIK Pogledaj Post
Tema je nepotrebna jer se o svim tim pitanjima raspravljalo i raspravlja se na temi tko je bog ...
Tamo je bosanski lonac. Ovdje se nadam da se tema neće raspasti budući da sam za razliku "Tko je Bog?" postavio preciznija logička pitanja.


Stone



Podijeli post!

chameleon je offline   Reply With Quote
chameleon, hvala ti na korisnom postu!
sinkezg (28-04-15)
Nepročitano 28-04-15, 20:52   #19
Guru
 
sinkezg's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: Oct 2009
Postovi: 2,414
sinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond repute
sinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond reputesinkezg has a reputation beyond repute
Zadani

sinkezg je offline   Reply With Quote
Hvala na korisnom postu!
chameleon (28-04-15), DeteSvetla6 (28-04-15), Jesam (29-04-15)
Nepročitano 28-04-15, 22:44   #20
.
 
DeteSvetla6's Avatar
 
Datum registracije: May 2009
Lokacija: .
Postovi: 8,604
DeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond repute
DeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond reputeDeteSvetla6 has a reputation beyond repute
Laughing eh liku dragi

Citat:
Originally Posted by LIK Pogledaj Post
Tema je nepotrebna jer se o svim tim pitanjima raspravljalo i raspravlja se na temi tko je bog ...
ne samo sto se nije raspravljalo vec niko na celom forumu nikada i ne postavi slicne logicke zakljucke
samo nas jedini kami srce nase najlogicnije
DeteSvetla6 je offline   Reply With Quote
Odgovor

Opcije Teme
Način Prikaza

Pravila Pisanja Postova
Vi ne možete otvoriti novu temu
Vi ne možete odgovarati na postove
Vi ne možete pridružiti datoteku
Vi ne možete editirati Vaše postove

BB kod je On
Smajlići su On
[IMG] kod je On
HTML kod je Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Vremenska Zona je GMT +1. Trenutno je 18:19 sati.





Iz ponude izdvajamo:















Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.0